AEW held their 2026 edition of Double or Nothing on May 24th. The show featured some big matches, including Darby Allin vs MJF, Samoa Joe vs Will Ospreay, and more. This page will feature all of the Dave Meltzer star ratings from AEW Double or Nothing 2026. These come via his Wrestling Observer Newsletter (you can subscribe at F4wonline.com).
Please subscribe to my WWE Youtube channel to support me.
Dave Meltzer Star Ratings – AEW Double or Nothing 2026
Kazuchika Okada vs Konosuke Takeshita
- RATING: 5.00 stars
Thekla vs Hikaru Shida vs Jamie Hayter vs Kris Statlander
- RATING: 3.25 stars
Samoa Joe vs Will Ospreay
- RATING: 4.5 stars
Bandido vs Swerve Strickland
- RATING: 4.75 stars
Athena vs Mina Shirakawa
- RATING: 3.00 stars
Jon Moxley vs Kyle O’Reilly
- RATING: 4.5 stars
Jericho, The Hurt Syndicate, and The Elite vs The Demand, The Don Callis Family, and The Dogs
- RATING: 4.75 stars
FTR vs Cage and Cope
- RATING: 5.00 stars
NOTE : Here are all of the 5 star matches in WWE history according to Dave.
Darby Allin vs MJF
- RATING: 4.75 stars
How did you rate these matches? Let me know in the comment section and please subscribe to us on Youtube to support us