Johnny Gargano has already put on some incredible matches in his WWE career. Here is a list of the Johnny Gargano matches that have received the most stars from Dave Meltzer of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter. Notes: the ratings are on a 5-star scale and we have only included matches with a 4-star rating and above.
Please subscribe to my WWE Youtube channel to support me.
The Highest Rated Johnny Gargano Matches Ever
The Following Johnny Gargano Matches Have Received 4.00 Stars
Johnny Gargano and Tommaso Ciampa vs The Young Bucks
Event: PWG All-Star Weekend XI (2015) | Rating: 4.00 Stars
- PWG Tag Team Championship match
Johnny Gargano vs Aleister Black vs Killian Dain vs Lars Sullivan
Event: NXT (December 27th, 2017) | Rating: 4.00 Stars
- Fatal 4-Way match
- Winner gets an NXT Championship match.
The Following Johnny Gargano Matches Have Received 4.25 Stars
Johnny Gargano and Tommaso Ciampa vs The Authors of Pain
Event: NXT Takeover: Chicago (2017) | Rating: 4.25 Stars
- NXT Tag Team Championship match
- Tag Team Ladder match
Johnny Gargano vs Andrade Almas
Event: NXT Takeover: Brooklyn III (2017) | Rating: 4.25 Stars
Johnny Gargano vs Andrade Almas
Event: NXT (February 21st, 2018) | Rating: 4.25 Stars
- NXT Championship match
- If Gargano lost, he would have had to leave NXT.
The Following Johnny Gargano Matches Have Received 4.5 Stars
Johnny Gargano and Tommaso Ciampa vs The Revival
Event: NXT Takeover: Brooklyn (2016) | Rating: 4.5 Stars
- NXT Tag Team Championship match
Johnny Gargano and Tommaso Ciampa vs The Revival
Event: NXT Takeover: Toronto (2016) | Rating: 4.5 Stars
- NXT Tag Team Championship match
- 2 out of 3 falls match.
Johnny Gargano and Tommaso Ciampa vs The Revival vs The Authors of Pain
Event: NXT Takeover: Orlando (2017) | Rating: 4.5 Stars
- NXT Tag Team Championship match
- Three-way tag team elimination
Johnny Gargano vs Tommaso Ciampa
Event: NXT Takeover: Chicago II (2018) | Rating: 4.5 Stars
- Chicago Street Fight
Johnny Gargano vs Tommaso Ciampa
Event: NXT Takeover: Brooklyn IV (2018) | Rating: 4.5 Stars
- NXT Championship match
- Last Man Standing
The Following Johnny Gargano Matches Have Received 4.75 Stars
Johnny Gargano vs Aleister Black
Event: NXT Takeover: War Games II (2018) | Rating: 4.75 Stars
Johnny Gargano vs Ricochet
Event: NXT Takeover: Phoenix (2019) | Rating: 4.75 Stars
- NXT North American Championship
The Following Johnny Gargano Matches Have Received 5.00 Stars
Johnny Gargano vs Andrade Almas
Event: NXT Takeover: Philadelphia (2018) | Rating: 5.00 Stars
- NXT Championship match
Johnny Gargano vs Tommaso Ciampa
Event: NXT Takeover: New Orleans (2018) | Rating: 5.00 Stars
- Unsanctioned match
Johnny Gargano vs Adam Cole
Event: NXT Takeover: New York (2019) | Rating: 5.5 Stars
- 2 out of 3 falls match for the NXT Championship.
READ NEXT: List Of The Highest-Rated AJ Styles Matches In WWE History
What are some of your favorite Johnny Gargano matches? Let us know in the comment section below.